Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-6433273-20170117033839/@comment-53539-20170120123130

Starlight-enterprise wrote: I know someone who made their own promotion for their really awful song that makes your ears bleed lol I honestly don't believe we're here to say what is and isn't good music, but we do have to have a tap, as I said "anyone can call themselves a producer". We shouldn't ever end up to the state where we're an exclusive club. So we always have to have a open door so anyone get on, but we also have to end things manageable.

So we can't really say we kept a song off the wikia because it was "ear bleeding". There are other calls we can make, but we're not here to judge the music itself. Just be aware of that. :-/

And yeah... To example myself, I don't think Circus-P's work is all that great compared to AndyS or Steampianoist, and thats an established artist with a fanbase I'm discussing. Nor do I think Daina's vocalist/Avanna's artist is that great of a producer herself. The song writer of songs like Pumpkin March doesn't always get mixing right for a song... But... There are people who would disagree with everything I just said.

But I hear what your saying, and yes... I would only really draw a line when a person has nothing but poorly mixed cover songs with VSQ/VSQX file slap-ins en masse myself. And even then, others here might disagree with that.

Its so hard to make the call, at least "don't make it yourself" is *something* that doesn't make us force to commit to call out what is and isn't good music.