Talk:Appetite of a People-Pleaser/@comment-53539-20171019085612/@comment-53539-20171020232054

Its not 100% true that we don't have vocaloids in English to cover rock songs, which is Flower's forte. Al and Ann are able to cover Classic Rock, though Ann is better at it and there are a number of examples on youtube of Ann doing rock pretty well. Then there is the issue of while we have none now that aren't dated like the pair, Zero-G was working on Rock genre of music, though hasn't released anything yet. Ergo, we not even see this release until V5.

On the other hand, Flower's not singing a song that really 100% fits a Rock style nor is singing in her best vocal range and is going high. To me, the fact remains is that while Flower may be built for rock, if the tempo was faster this would be a pop song through and through. And since she isn't singing in her lower range for the most of it, she isn't giving us the rock voice that she allows in the first place.

That should be enough on Flower's specialised area in regards to this song.

As for the whole "we have no Engloids that are at a fast tempo"... Well... I again look at Nana's tempo range and its recommended for this song. Saying that, Ura-omote Lovers has a fast paced Miku, and she is throughout the song falling apart and her vocal collapses, to the point it wouldn't have mattered if she was realistic or not. I don't think Vocaloid handles quick tempos at all well, as it ends up sounding more machine then the mid-paced songs. Song ballards can sound much better, and few Vocaloid producers can make a Vocaloid sound good enough for them, as it requires a lot more work.

Hey, I must say this is a interesting topic, if anything Ghost should be congratulated for getting us to seriously discuss the topics we are. We.... Kinda sit there and don't really discuss a song or Vocaloids this well in depth, its nice... I wish we did it more often.