Board Thread:Wiki Discussion/@comment-53539-20130615162805

Okay every time we have a discussion on how to improve these we come to a bit of a stand-off.

The problem;


 * The Strengths/weakness sections are problematic as things are not always so clear
 * NOT having S/W means the readers don't aways understand how vocaloids are good and bad.

The solution;

Thats just it...

I've seen a few other editors try to get around this and I've suggested myself reducing the S/W to bullet-point like status, but nothing has come of this. So I'm bringing this up once again.

So... Seriously, we need to improve this section because the vocals aren't black and white. On the one hand, I don't know how to avoid this problem we've got with how to write it out. I've rattled my brains on this one for months.

Xey suggest replacing the S/W with a "traits" section, but we've be back with the problem we had that caused the S/W method to appear. If you've noticed, even I've been focred to put someinformation in "additional notes" section on some pages because they didn't really belong there.

On the S/W section alone, if they are to be kept I think we need to decide just *what* counts as a S/W.

I think the "traits section" could be actually expanded on, as for some vocaloids I think we need to have a highlighted section on their phonetic oddities under some sort of "Phonetic notes".

In the meantime, since I've gotten in Bunai's bad books today over the MMD galleries... I dared try to play with these sections without giving 24 hours notice to everyone else.

Look listen guys, can we at LEAST discuss this and come to some sort of conclusion... The only reason I've gone ahead with things without asking in the last few months is I've pretty much given up asking for others input because we only seem to give it AFTER somethings come up. I hate guessing what everyone wants, now I'm serious about this. =_= 