Talk:Appetite of a People-Pleaser/@comment-34315952-20180112233629/@comment-53539-20180113144918

Well on a technically level, it wasn't very good and even Ghost admitted they didn't have the skills to make a better version with alternative vocaloids who would have covered it better, for example. They were fairly open and honest about the problems of the song and were very caring about the song, they interacted with the opinions of others when they responded here on the wikia to the criticism. This makes them a good producer as a person if you ask me. I can think of at least one famous western producer who was rude at times to criticism.

This shouldn't impact if a person likes or dislikes a song. Remember that in V2, the Kagamines had some of the poorest quality vocals, yet they had many fans. Quality of a song should not impact ones love or dislike of it. Not everyone like the same style and people are entitled to love a song if it is very good or very bad. I don't tend to like Justin Bieber or Lady Gaga or even KAty Perry myself as singers. Some dislike Opera singers, even though Opera singers have to use far more skill to create their voice then the average opera singer. And as for Rap... Its like Marmite, you either love it or hate it.

Others have picked on Ghost for a while from what I've heard, which is unfortunate and sad. Its one thing to criticise a song, but another to just constantly put down a producer. A lot of the problems is that a lot of the songs they make have had many similar problems and people are constantly pointing them out. I myself wasn't aware of most of it when I started criticising the song.

Some of it is circumstances purely, as Ghost is a good producer in the making but got attention too soon to match their skills. This can make or break a producer quite badly due to pressure to improve fast. There have been plenty of good producers who didn't get much fame in the opposite directly and quit because of lack of interest... Both cases can lead to disaster for a bidding producer. But then again, every producer has to start somewhere... And there are plenty of examples of VSQ/VSQX slap-in producers who do really bad cover songs.