User blog comment:Gohan3256/What's wrong with SeeU?/@comment-5051846-20120619183536

I always thought comparing a Vocaloid to a Vocaloid with such a difference in release dates as SeeU and Miku was a bit odd.

Several years are between them. It just wouldn't come to mind as someone to compare a new release to. I can only reach the dire conclusion that the commenters who compare V3s to Miku have never heard of any other Vocaloids released between Miku and aforementioned V3.

D:

Usually you compare things that are related. Just because they are both Vocaloids doesn't inspire me enough. I would think comparing Vocaloids of a similar tempo, range and optimum pitch as logical. Or Vocaloids released at the same time, as they are likely to have the same level of advancement technologically. SeeU and Miku even voicebanks made for completely different languages! Erk. You can't draw valid conclusions from that.

As to whether both Miku and SeeU are both excellent...I dunno. My version of excellent has a big critieria that is based on professional real singers as well as other Vocaloids. (I am harsh.) And Miku is getting on in years. I'll rethink when she gets a V3.