Board Thread:Wiki Discussion/@comment-35301431-20130617151144/@comment-35301431-20130707020326

Depending on the status of a song there shouldn't be a category stating "songs featuring x" because that was not the intention of a song's release.


 * Rose+Thorn was sung by an UTAU first. The official revise is done by the producer (Empath), she made it a point to have it be Avanna as lead. Leon was used as an available English male and he is included on a previous arrangement and the piano version. Same would go for Anonymous, first done by human and even rearranged to what it is now. Avanna's is an album release while Kaito covers the preview version with V3; so both are official and no avoiding in not mentioning them.


 * Byakkoya no Musume features one Vocaloid and that is Lola, while Kaito has a popular cover. So I am not sure why LaZMMiSY added it back. The song is not a direct original Vocaloid song, and though it is covered by other Vocaloids it shouldn't mean adding more of them to a song others were not originally a part of.


 * Tsukema Tsukeru, again popularized by Vocaloid but it doesn't mean it should be categorized with a Vocaloid based on popularity of a cover.


 * Make me Feel and Pomogi mne tebya ponyat, from what I understand is like BnoM, not intentionally a Vocaloid song, though they were used to demo a Vocaloid. The Russian version is the cover. You could count the English version as a cover based on it being recorded by a human much later.


 * Hannya Shingyou is a chant, so while Miku covers a large chunk of them there shouldn't be a category stating by Miku. In opinion. Similar with Ievan Polkka.