Board Thread:Wiki Discussion/@comment-53539-20130726185551

Are we really doing this thing now???

Should we now make other pages like this because hell, what makes this girl so special, we've had a situation where there was no name before and we waited???

She has no name. Really... At the most this should be a sandbox page and not a actual page. I'll talk about when the One Piece wikia used to do this and why they eventually decided to go sharp on this. While ?I don't like using another wikia as a justification for why we shouldn't do it ourselves, I've only ever used other wikias to talk from experience, when they did things like this it created lots of problems over time.

Basically, its the same reason wikipedia has rules against it is for those problems, it becomes unprofessional looking because people are less likely to look up a descriptive name then a actual name of something. And they insist a page with a vague name should be kept on a sandbox and not made into a actual page until the a proper official name is brought in because it DOES create problems...

And what happens witht he next vocaloid who is a feminie Spanish vocal, do you see the problem with this name page? Your creating more work, because now someone has to delete the page when she is done because it *may* happen again. Guys, think about this

And really, we've HAD experience with this in the past descriptive names are used for a page and look at just the criticism that was brought up on THAt. Further more, I get the diea someone is just taking the piss out of the wikia after all the bickering recently over Zunko, Kamui and the twogirls from the game that was confirmed to have vocaloid bcking their game.

If this is a knee-jerk reaction to all this stuff; I'm done witht he wikia because this whole issue is going too far. No one is talking about this, there are just onjection and now it feels like a page has been created out of protest, not good faith... 