Forum:Proposal for Standardization of Song Pages

Basically I feel there is a need for standardization of Song Pages (the ones in the “Vocaloid Original Song” category though more may apply that I haven’t noticed), namely in the “Derivative Works” section as there are many things that make it look rather “messy”.

Some of the songs may or may not be relevant to put in that section. Because there are no rules on what one may or may not add (like for example no restrictions on view counts), this section can be easily taken advantage of and filled with videos that may not be entirely relevant. Also with no restrictions a lot of bias can be added, for example someone could link a utattemita by a utaite that doesn’t have many views (I understand that unpopular artists can be much better than popular ones) but rules and regulations need to be more substantial ie.more views = more popular = more people like it. I’ll hate to put it like this, but the songs, video, cover, etc. should have status to back up why it should be listed in the first place. I also noticed some inconsistencies in terms of sorting as well.

If this has a positive feedback then I shall post a list of the "standardizations" I had in mind.

I apologize if there is some sort of guideline already available as I can't seem to find any.

Hopefully I didn’t sound aggressive since that was not my intention to do so.

Sen (talk) 05:59, September 17, 2012 (UTC)