Talk:VOCALOID CHINA/@comment-5057772-20130406185402/@comment-35301431-20130406203402

I think it has to do with the obvious presentation, Yayin Gongyu was originally written to have a character item, likes and dislikes, and even a brief history. Basically everything was laid out to follow what was present in the fandom for years. Though she was talked about as being a literal Fanmade Vocaloid that follows a common pattern. As for Iroha, no one figured that the character would become a Vocaloid. She was (still is) a part of a project by Sanrio, her story and personality was created for the project specifically so it wasn't Vocaloid intended. Some people see her Kittyler persona as being different from her Vocaloid persona. I personally want to get a translation to fill out an extra section on her page. Kiyoteru situation is sort of like a reverse Iroha. If you are referring to the Ice Mountain thing. That is a doujin take on the mascot, much like Miku being presented in many PVs with many personalities or KEI doing a manga featuring Crypton Vocaloids and being acknowledged, but still viewed as unofficial. Since I don't pay attention to CUL, I have no say on her. But if the novel was released in May 2012 then that shouldn't effect the criticism of Yayin Gongyu's history.