Vocaloid Wiki talk:Proposed Fanmade Vocaloids

The thing is, while I respect peoples' desire to keep the main fanmade page clear of spam and organized, this page is nothing more than a critique page of fanmade vocaloids that have been deemed "unworthy" by someone, and these vocaloid characters are just as fanmade as any of the others possibly more so than some. Most of the vocaloid characters on this page have the "issues" of thing like 'lack of promotion', 'name origin needs to be specified(or this japanese name needs to be corrected/rewritten in kanji and katakan)', and 'sounds like a live singer'. Well the fact is, not all people who voice their own vocaloids want to be like the nico user who edits her voice to sound like a vocaloid for the voice of sai but they want their character to HAVE a voice be it based off of another vocaloid, live, or truly being an utau, because I've noticed alot of characters with faces and that's it, they don't have a voice which defeats the point of both vocaloid and utau, next some names are made up and not all people know japanese fluently but try their best anyways, and "lack of promotion"? now that's just silly, it's not like anyone can use the voice of a fanmade vocaloid unless it's based off of another vocaloid (ie kikaito's voice comes from kaito), fanart won't just appear out of no where, you have to become popular enough to get it and some of the vocaloids on this page have more of a fan base than the ones on the main page that ONLY hit this site which was the original problem I've never heard of, seen, or found any other links to Giru Kyoune (sorry if I'm picking on your character, I just picked one with the same issues as the ones on this page so...) she may have a "proper" name, but that's about it she has a deviant account but I can't find any other pics of her but the one on the main page.....that's what I have to say about that, if you're going to be critical on some of the fanmades, you should bring the others up to the same standards that you're trying to hold us to.TheNextVocaloid 19:44, 22 May 2009 (UTC)